Christmas Pie List

Accepting orders for Christmas starting Saturday, Nov. 27 until Sunday, Dec. 19 at 3 pm.



Potato Filling $3.75/pound

We are making a maximum of 350 pounds. First come first serve!


Hot Bacon Dressing $4.00/pint $8.00/quart


Homemade Cole Slaw,

Pepper Cabbage, Chow Chow,

Pickled Beets

$ 4.00/pint $8.00/quart


Pickup will be from 8 am until 1 pm on Friday, Dec. 24.


Phone orders only. Please no orders through text, email, Facebook, or other social media.


We will be closed for regular business Mon. Dec. 20 until Tues. Dec. 28, reopening at 4 pm on Wed. Dec. 29.


Open Fri. Dec. 24, 8 am to 1 pm for order pickup and gift certificate sales only.


We will be baking a maximum of 50 apple pies (all varieties), 30 pumpkin pies, and 30 deep dish custards.

Apple Crumb $17


Caramel Apple Crumb $19


Apple Walnut Cheese Crumb $19


Apple-Pear Crumb $17


Apple Tart (no crumbs) $17


Cherry Crumb $17


Cherry-Blueberry Crumb $17


Blueberry-Peach Crumb $17


Peach Crumb $17


Raisin Crumb $17


Lemon Sponge $17


Blueberry Custard $17


Blueberry-Raspberry Custard $17


Bourbon Buttermilk Custard $17


Coconut Custard $17

Pumpkin $17

Molasses Coconut $17

Coconut Pecan $17


Coconut Cream $17


Pecan $17


Bourbon Choc. Chip Pecan $18


Funny Cake $17


French Silk $17


Peanut Butter $17


Shoofly $17


Amish Vanilla $17


Deep Dish Egg Custard $24


Deep Dish Blueberry Custard $24


Deep Dish Blueberry-Raspberry Custard $24


Deep Dish Red Raspberry Custard $24


Deep Dish Coconut Custard $24

Cakes and cheesecakes will not be available.