Homemade Desserts

Take home a whole homemade dessert to enjoy with family and friends! Choose from our extensive selection of popular classics and PA Dutch favorites.

Most pies are available with a day's notice, deep dish custards, cakes, and cheesecakes are available with 2 days' notice, and PieCakens with 5 days' notice.

Any item marked with an * indicates a seasonal product not available all year long.

Certain items are not available during the Thanksgiving and Christmas holidays.

Please inquire before ordering. Whole desserts are for sale to go only.
Orders are taken by phone at 610-562-8520 or in person.
Orders will not be accepted through our website or social media.

PIES

Apple Crumb $21
Apple w/ lid $23
Caramel Apple Crumb $23
Apple Walnut Cheese Crumb $23
Apple-Pear Crumb $21
Apple Tart (no crumbs or lid) $21
Cherry Crumb $22
Cherry w/ lid $24
Cherry-Blueberry Crumb $21
Blueberry-Peach Crumb $21
Blueberry-Peach w/ lid $23
Raspberry-Peach Crumb $21
Raspberry-Peach w/lid $23
Peach Crumb $21
Peach w/ lid $23
Strawberry-Peach Crumb* $21
Strawberry-Peach w/ lid $23
Rhubarb Crumb* $21
Strawberry Rhubarb Crumb* $21
Raisin Crumb $21
Lemon Sponge $21
Fresh Strawberry* $21
Glazed Strawberry Cream* $21
Rhubarb Custard* $21
Blueberry Custard $21
Peach Custard $21
Blueberry-Peach Custard $21
Red Raspberry Custard $21

Raspberry-Peach Custard $21
Blueberry-Raspberry Custard $21
Pumpkin Custard* $21
Buttermilk Custard $21
Chocolate Buttermilk Custard $21
Bourbon Buttermilk Custard $21
Coconut Custard $21
Peaches & Cream $21
Blueberry Lemon Cream $21
Molasses Coconut $21
Coconut Pecan $21
Coconut Cream $21
Pecan $21
Chocolate Pecan $21
Bourbon Choc. Chip Pecan Pie $22
Almond Macaroon $21
German Chocolate $21
Chocolate Chip $18
Walnut Molasses $21
Oatmeal Pie $18
Funny Cake $21
Peanut Butter $21
French Silk $21
Amish Vanilla $21
Milk Pie $16
Shoofly $21
Key Lime $21

All Deep Dish Custard Pies $26
Egg Custard, Blueberry, Blueberry-Peach,
Blueberry-Red Raspberry, Peach, Red Raspberry, Rhubarb Custard,* Coconut, Pumpkin*

Cakes - 9” Two Layer

Chocolate Cake with Vanilla, Chocolate, Peanut Butter, or Chocolate Chip Mint Frosting $28

Vanilla Cake with Vanilla or Chocolate Frosting $28

Carrot Cake $28
Coconut Cake $28

Red Velvet Cake $28

PieCaken

Red velvet cake on top of cheesecake
on top of pecan pie, covered with vanilla butter cream frosting. No substitutions. 5 days notice needed. $60

Cheesecakes

Cheesecake (NY Style) 9” $35
Cherry Cheesecake $42